Document Actions

The Wireless Video Surveillance Opportunity: Why WiMAX is not just for Broadband Wireless Access

Despite the media's predominant focus on whether or not WiMAX will "win" over LTE as the 4G technology of choice, it is important to realize that WiMAX's future is not tied to BWA alone.

If you take a look at the WiMAX headlines on any given day, you'll notice that a vast majority of the coverage WiMAX receives focuses on broadband wireless access (BWA) - regardless of whether that coverage is praising the technology for its performance and ability to provide service to underserved areas, or whether its questioning the technology's viability as the 4G technology of choice. Don't get me wrong - WiMAX is absolutely deserving of its role in shaping the 4G and BWA landscape moving forward. The WiMAX Forum itself defines WiMAX as "a standards-based technology enabling the delivery of last mile wireless broadband access as an alternative to cable and DSL".

But, that's not the whole WiMAX story.

WiMAX can be - and often is - used for a wide variety of applications outside of last mile access. The technology was originally designed with wireless backhaul as one of the primary use cases (as opposed to the afterthought it seems to be in most coverage of the technology), and its ability to provide high-throughput wireless backhaul makes it an ideal candidate for deploying bandwidth-intensive applications.

But there is one burgeoning market in particular that WiMAX has carved out a well-defined niche in, and that is the video surveillance market. This is a market whose growth has exploded over the past 5 years, and that ABI Research forecasts will be a $41 billion a year market by 2014.

This explosive growth and continued market potential is due to an increasing need for video surveillance to help secure the world's ports, airports, cities and transportation infrastructure as well as schools, hospitals, government and other critical environments. Now more than ever, organizational demands have hastened our search for better, more cost-effective security applications, and in many instances, rapid deployment of security systems has become essential. But as critical as improved security has become, budgets to accomplish this goal are by no means unlimited.

Organizations of all kinds are being challenged to install video surveillance in areas that are too remote, too costly or physically impossible to reach with additional cabling. As a result, wireless solutions have been a boon to the video surveillance market as they enable the ability to cost-effectively leap over these barriers, allowing a virtually unlimited number of video surveillance cameras to be deployed quickly, easily and affordably.

In particular, WiMAX has emerged as the premiere solution to provide the wireless backhaul and transmission of real-time video surveillance. As a wireless WAN technology, WiMAX was designed specifically with the efficient backhaul of broadband data, voice and video at its core. Unlike wireless mesh technologies, which provide unpredictable service for backhauling streaming video, WiMAX is deterministic with built in scheduled access and Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms to ensure the reliable delivery of video.

In a WiMAX-enabled video surveillance system, high resolution, real-time video from each security camera in the network is transmitted from multiple subscriber units to a base station which is then backhauled via a wireless Point to Point radio to the regional security center which controls all of the cameras. As a result, the use of WiMAX provides the following advantages:

  • Eliminates the massive costs and delays of trenching for fiber
  • Quickly deployed and configured - operational within hours
  • Deploys virtually anywhere - across rugged terrain, bodies of water and remote areas
  • Carrier-class reliability ensures non-stop security
  • High capacity, configurable and secure broadband wireless for guaranteed QoS
  • Enables real-time transmission from and control of surveillance cameras
  • When integrated with Wi-Fi networks, allows remote and mobile monitoring (via PDAs, PCs, laptops, etc.) and increases ROI

Cost-Effective

Fiber based networks cost significantly more to deploy than an equivalent WiMAX system, often about 5x-10x more. Deploying new broadband copper networks is as expensive as fiber networks and is impractical for medium to long range deployments. WiMAX is not only more cost-effective, but it also provides the added benefit of scalability based on bandwidth requirements.

Quickly Deployed

Availability of copper and fiber is dependent on the location, making the upgrading of existing wired infrastructure economically impractical in many areas. WIMAX, on the other hand, can be deployed virtually anywhere, including over bodies of water, rugged terrain, and remote locations. WiMAX networks can install in hours or days (instead of weeks or months), eliminating long waiting periods and right-of-way issues associated with trenching for fiber.

Flexible and Scalable

In many cases the deployment of wired solutions requires trenching, which can cause any number of problems. Not only is it much more expensive, but in scenarios where direct trenching would require tearing down a historic building or trenching through a busy intersection, it quickly becomes unfeasible.

WiMAX solutions, in contrast, provide unparalleled flexibility. If the security network uses wireless infrastructure for connectivity, cameras need not be permanently located next to the wired network connection. As necessary, cameras and subscriber units can be moved to a new location and can be reconnected within minutes. Carrier-class WiMAX solutions are available for even the most large scale video surveillance deployments, and are available in ruggedized enclosures for deployment in all weather conditions. More economical solutions are also available for smaller, more budget conscious deployments.

Highly Reliable

High-end WiMAX systems support up to 99.999% availability, enabling virtually non-stop monitoring and surveillance. A wireless system with 99.999% availability has only 5 minutes of downtime in an entire year.

High Capacity

Video is a bandwidth intensive application and imposes stringent bandwidth requirements. Wired networks often do not scale quick enough to meet the growing bandwidth demand. But with WiMAX's ability to provide 54 Mbps of bandwidth, it is perfectly suited for the quick build out of high capacity networks.

Mobile

The inherent un-tethered nature of WiMAX products simplifies deploying mobile systems. This includes the transporting of large amounts of data to vehicles for mobile video monitoring. This is achieved by deploying mobile subscriber units in law enforcement vehicles, which receive video from fixed base station units. As a result, police vehicles can view real-time streaming video surveillance of a crime scene as the drive to the scene, enabling them to be more prepared upon arrival.

Remember WiMAX's Bigger Picture

As easy as it is to get caught up in all the "WiMAX vs. LTE" hype, it is important that we remember to consider the bigger picture when it comes to WiMAX as a technology. WiMAX is not solely a last-mile access technology, and its future is not pinned solely to its success as a 4G access technology. Many high-bandwith applications - and especially the rapidly growing, multi-billion dollar a year video surveillance market - are wholly dependent on high-performance wireless backhaul and connectivity solutions, and point-to-multipoint technologies like WiMAX fit the bill perfectly for delivering those applications.

I'll be talking about other applications for WiMAX/point-to-multipoint technology in the coming weeks, too, to highlight the many market opportunities for the technology. In the meantime, as you follow the media coverage of WiMAX and its future prospects, just remember that it's a big wide wireless world out there, and last-mile BWA is not the only game in town for WiMAX.



Robb Henshaw is the Director of Marketing & Communications at Proxim Wireless, a manufacturer of end-to-end broadband wireless systems, where he oversees the company's global marketing and communications efforts.  For the last 8 years he has been dedicated to helping develop the wireless industry, with expertise in technologies ranging from enterprise WLANs, to carrier-grade wireless backhaul, to WiMAX and point-to-multipoint broadband wireless access (BWA) solutions.




 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
_____
tags:
Wednesday, August 26, 2009 in Applications  | Permalink |  Comments (10)

Don't see WiMAX used for backhaul of video surveillance traffic

Posted by Alan J Weissberger at 2009-08-27 09:24 AM
My friend and mentor Suhas Patil is the head of Cradle Technologies, which specializes in networked video surveillance solutions. http://cradle.com/

I have another friend- Basant Khaitan- who has a video surveillance software company in Calcutta.

Neither Suhas or Basant said anything about WiMAX being used "to provide the wireless backhaul and transmission of real-time video surveillance." In fact, I've asked them and they say they don't see WiMAX at all for this application.

I think the majority of the backhaul for video surveillance is wired transport- mostly copper (e.g. bonded DS1/E1 or DS3/E3)! And if wireless backhaul (pt to pt transmission) was used, it seems proprietary solutions would be more cost effective.

Can you provide even ONE example of WiMAX being used/ planned for wireless backhaul and transmission of real-time video surveillance?

Thanks

Alan Weissberger
wimax360 Moderator

RE: Don't see WiMAX used for backhaul of video surveillance traffic

Posted by Robb Henshaw at 2009-08-28 09:17 AM
Hi Alan,

I can provide a lot of examples of active deployments where WiMAX is used to backhaul video surveillance. Here's one:http://blog.quantumwimax.com/proxim-uses-wimax-for-turkey’s-video-surveillance-network

And here's an example of a deployment using WiMAX to connect a weather detection/traffic safety system in California, which includes video cameras as a piece of the system: http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9128619/WiMax_system_warns_drivers_on_dangerous_highway_prone_to_dense_fog

I find it very interesting that your friends have never seen this and are not pursuing this as a solution in their businesses. Ask Axis Communications (one of the largest video surveillance camera manufacturers) or ADT (Fortune 500 company that deploys tons of video surveillance networks), and both of them will tell you that WiMAX is a great solution for video networks.

Best,
Robb

WiMAX for Video surveillance service

Posted by Amit Shivhare at 2009-08-31 08:53 AM
Hi Alan,

I agree with you and robb both. You are right WiMAX is not very popular as a video sureillance backhaul but its not necesary that if its not popular as of now can not be used. Technically I am not seeing any roadblock in WiMAX to use as a backhaul for video surveillance.

Even in India one of the WiMAX operator is coming up with the the video sureillance service for retail segment on WiMAX network.

Regards
Amit

The Entire Ecosystem Must Thrive

Posted by Robert Syputa at 2009-08-31 08:53 AM
Wireless is a field that is highly dependent on the supply ecosystem for each successive generation or standard of WRAN, wireless radio access network.

Proxim is aware of this probably more than most: Proxim originated from Western Wireless, a proprietary WBA supplier, acquired/merged with Proxim, a pioneer in the WiFi field that rose rapidly early in the decade. The proprietary wireless products segments were impacted by the WiFi ecosystem, both by the use of WiFi LANs and adaptations that were used as much lower cost PtP and local cloud networks. WiFi MESH also played a role in establishing the new technology ecosystem beyond its original intent to serve as neighborhood and metro area clouds (I always questioned the viability of metroFi use - the results are by now pretty obvious). Western Wireless saw that the their proprietary business was threatened, sales had already been hit, so they acquired Proxim and took on the new name. Although technically an acquisition, it worked out almost the other way around: Proxim drove the agenda for the merged company upon the growth of WiFi.

Alvarion and other WBA specialists used the benefits of the mass market WiFi ecosystem by adopting Atheros chips into their PtM hardware, using their own MAC. Similarly today we see several 'WiMAX like' products on the market: products that are based on the 802.16d or .16e ecosystem chips, antennas, RFICs, and much of the same software and MIMO-AAS algorithms to build systems for use in spectrum bands or specific classes of use that are not part of the WiMAX Forum system profiles and certifications process. As far as the objectives of the suppliers is concerned, they benefit from the WiMAX ecosystem developed for what are often more mainstream markets to pursue niche/specialized classes of applications including video surveillance.

That works fine to benefit both the supplier and clients.. the business case model can make every bit of sense: performance, acceptably low cost, diversity and reliability of component supply, proven reliability by extension from other markets, simplified inventory for parts and modularized product units, etc.

But what an individual case example does not take into account is the dependence or inter-dependence of markets for products: if the WiMAX ecosystem fails to develop mass market applications then it will fall victim to cost disadvantages similar to the way old Western Wireless fell victim to the onslaught of mass market use of 802.11 WiFi.

"We are all in this together"

A major communications standard depends on creating a lively R&D and supply ecosystem. The larger volume mass market applications do much of the heavy lifting of chip, RFIC, MAC and extended development that makes the specialty applications viable.

That is why the goals of the overall effort cannot afford to be swayed so much by the immediate low hanging fruit to distract from the broader context of development.. without the likely root system, the fruit baring tree dies.

Video is a growing need. But Alan is right: similarly, the 'Smart Grid' application area is often touted as being a boon to WiMAX. But if you ask utilities most will say that they now use and will consider a range of communications from dial up modem modules to WiFi links and MESH, 3G, WiMAX, LTE... whatever is most readily available, meets cost objectives, integrates as needed into larger networks. WiMAX can be an attractive alternative for video because it is designed to meet the bandwidth, latency and jitter needed. And networks can be laid out into grids for a good measure of redundancy. But the same can be said for LTE as well. The selection will depend on what is available, at what cost, in what spectrum, etc.

Video on WiMax

Posted by Paresh Patel at 2009-09-03 10:59 AM
Hello Alan,
On our planned WiMax network for India we will be providing video surveillance services to corporate customers. This is the most cost effictive way for the remote locations of manufacturing facilities as is the case in India. Most of the WiMax network within an urban area will be for Internet services but the outlying base stations can be used for video surveillance.
Paresh Patel

Teltonika WiMAX Camera

Posted by bermandt at 2009-09-16 01:04 PM
Hi Allan, Teltonika has WiMAX Video Camera, you can read here : http://www.wimaxian.com/2009/09/11/teltonika-unveiled-wimax-video-camera-and-wimax-router/

Video surveillance over WiMAX

Posted by Timo van 't Zelfde at 2009-09-01 09:36 AM
Hi Alan,

I can give you several example's of WiMAX enabled video surveillance. Here in Amsterdam, we (Worldmax Operations) have signed a partnership with Cameramanager.com to create a cost effective and easy to install video surveillance, enabled by WiMAX technology. Have a look at http://www.cameramanager.com for the product offering.

We have also installed a WiMAX enabled video system on a classic salon boat, which tours through the canals in Amsterdam. You can watch live video through a public video stream at http://www.denederlanden.com/webcam-amsterdam-rondvaart.html (note: when the boat is not in use, the camera is switched off).

So, in my opinion, WiMAX is a great technology for supporting all kinds of video activities.

Best regards from the WiMAX city of Amsterdam.

Video cam

Posted by John at 2009-09-03 04:37 PM
It appears the WiMax video camera in Amsterdam has a broken lens. The quality is nothing to brag about either. To be the next solution for remote video I believe the quality will need to be excellent and thus will require more bandwidth. I am not certain if WiMax can compete dollar for dollar with a high resolution surveillance solution?

WiMax for 15 video cameras

Posted by Juan Rodriguez at 2009-11-20 03:34 PM
I would like to implement a video serveillance network for my residential area in Puerto Rico. Is a mountain area over an area of 1 mile average with approx 15 cameras. Please advice the best place to get the Wimax equipment as well as the cameras with ancillary equipment.
I have a good knowlege of propagation and microwave networks however never have the operotunity to work with this video/Wimax system.

Thanks,
Juan H. Rodriguez

Replying to Juan H. Rodriguez

Posted by Joe Mirolli at 2009-12-15 06:28 PM
Juan,
in reading your post, it seams as though your individual need may be best suited for Proxim's wireless ap technologies. Wimax is offered as service similar to a utilities company. You should check out Proxim's website or consult with a qualified IT company that specializes in IP CCTV. I know of a good one, and be happy to travel to the sunny warm islands this time of year. I would recommend against designing a cctv system that is a secondary service to the wireless Ethernet at this stage when you have the ability to pre-plan for both. Instead look at the two technologies together and plan the wireless accordingly based on both needs.

JM
Assurance Media.net



Vendor Directory

Looking for a WiMAX Company?

Join the Directory!

Global WiMAX Subscribers
SPONSORED BY:

How many global WiMAX subscribers will there be in 2013?

Less than 20M
20M - 50M
50M - 80M
80M - 120M
Over 120M

WiMax.com RSS Feeds

RSS WiMax.com Blog

RSS WiMAX Industry News

RSS WiMAX FAQ


WiMAX360 | Deployment | Equipment | Applications | Business | Vendor | Resources | Training | About Us
"WiMAX Forum™” and "WiMAX CERTIFIED™“ are registered trademarks of the WiMAX Forum™.

 news : privacy : terms of use : about_us : advertising : feedback  : corporate profile

 

© 2010 WiMax.com Broadband Solutions, Inc.